In Toni Morrison’s Recitatif, the way she leaves things a bit unclear and doesn’t spell out the characters’ races is a big part of how she digs into themes like identity, memory, and the messy nature of race. By keeping Twyla and Roberta’s racial backgrounds under wraps, Morrison pushes readers to face their own biases and assumptions while also looking at how made-up racial categories shape our relationships with each other.

A key example of this ambiguity is when Morrison talks about why Twyla and Roberta ended up together in the orphanage—it was because people thought their moms weren’t good enough. Twyla mentions that “there was something about [Roberta’s] mother that wasn’t right,” and Roberta says something similar about Twyla’s mom. These vague comments let readers fill in the blanks with their own racial stereotypes, showing just how much our preconceived ideas about race can affect our views on morality and behavior.

Another moment of confusion pops up when Twyla and Roberta clash during the busing protests. Their argument shows the racial tensions from the 1970s, but Morrison doesn’t make it clear which character belongs to which racial group. Readers might end up assigning roles based on how they see the characters’ social backgrounds and attitudes. This uncertainty highlights that prejudice is something everyone deals with, and that racial identity can be pretty fluid.

Lastly, Maggie, the quiet kitchen worker, becomes a key point for digging into how race ties in with memory and guilt. Twyla and Roberta can’t agree on whether Maggie was Black or not—a question that remains unanswered. Their different memories show us how personal experiences, biases, and social situations shape what we remember. The unclear racial identity of Maggie really drives home the story’s theme about racial complexity, showing that our views on race often reflect our own biases rather than any objective truth.

By breaking down rigid ideas about race, Morrison encourages readers to look at their own biases and think about how identity can change. She also wants us to recognize the common humanity we all share, despite the divisions society puts on us.

This entry is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International license.